Sow & Tell
Plant look-alikes: 14 pairs that are easy to mix up
Some garden and wild plants look almost the same, and a few of the mix-ups are dangerous. Each one below gives the quick rule first, then the feature-by-feature difference, from university Extension and state conservation sources.
When you are not certain, do not eat it and do not handle it bare-handed. No photograph or description replaces an identification you are sure of.
Wild carrot vs. poison hemlock and water hemlock
All of these have lacy leaves and flat clusters of small white flowers, so they are easy to mix up. Poison hemlock and water hemlock can kill if eaten, so a mistake here can be fatal.
The quick rule: No hairs on the stem? Purple spots or streaks? Don't touch it, don't taste it. When in doubt, treat every wild carrot-family plant as deadly.
- Wild carrot — Edible
The stem is hairy all over at every stage, with no purple spots, and long forked bracts sit under the flower cluster. - Poison hemlock — Deadly
A smooth, hairless, hollow stem with purple or red spots and blotches. - Water hemlock — Deadly
Leaf side veins run to the notches between the teeth, not to the tips, and it grows in wet ground. - Yarrow — Harmless
Each flat cluster is made of many tiny daisy-like heads, and the fern-like leaves have a strong spicy smell.
| Feature | Wild carrot (Queen Anne's lace) | Poison hemlock | Water hemlock | Yarrow |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Stem | Hairy (bristly) all over, no purple spots | Smooth, hairless, often waxy, hollow, with purple or red spots and blotches | Smooth, hairless, hollow, with purple streaks or mottling | |
| Height | Usually about 2 feet, rarely much taller | 3 to 8 feet, sometimes taller | 2 to 8 feet | 1 to 3 feet |
| Smell of crushed leaves | Sweet, like carrot | Musty or unpleasant, like mouse urine | Strong and spicy | |
| Leaves | Feathery and lacy, with narrow segments | Glossy, hairless, finely cut and fern-like | Coarser, with narrow, toothed, lance-shaped leaflets; side veins end in the notches between teeth | Fern-like, finely divided, aromatic |
| Flower cluster | Flat, lacy white umbel 2 to 4 inches wide, often with one dark purple floret in the center (not always there, so don't rely on it alone) and long forked bracts underneath | Many small white umbels, all-white, with no forked bracts underneath | White umbrella-shaped umbels | Flat-topped clusters of tiny daisy-like flower heads, not an umbrella of stalks |
| Where it grows | Roadsides, ditches and pastures; likes wet soil but also grows in drier spots | Wet ground: stream and pond banks, marshes, wet meadows, swamps and ditches |
Sources: mdc.mo.gov, mdc.mo.gov, extension.oregonstate.edu, uaex.uada.edu, plants.ces.ncsu.edu, plants.ces.ncsu.edu
Cow parsnip vs. giant hogweed and wild parsnip
These tall carrot-family plants all have sap that burns skin when it meets sunlight. Giant hogweed is the worst: its burns can scar for years and sap in the eyes can blind, and it is a federal noxious weed that should be reported.
The quick rule: Don't touch any giant umbrella-flowered plant with bare skin. Taller than you, with purple-blotched, bristly stems? Report it as giant hogweed.
- Cow parsnip — harmful
Stem is 1 to 2 inches thick with fine white hairs, and the white flower heads are up to about 1 foot wide. - Giant hogweed — harmful
Huge: 7 to 14 feet tall, with a 2- to 4-inch stem covered in purple blotches and coarse white bristles. - Wild parsnip — harmful
Flowers are yellow, not white, and the grooved stem has no hairs.
| Feature | Cow parsnip | Giant hogweed | Wild parsnip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Height | 5 to 8 feet | 7 to 14 feet | Up to about 5 feet |
| Stem | 1 to 2 inches thick, green and grooved, with fine white hairs | 2 to 4 inches thick, with purple blotches and coarse white bristles | Up to 1.5 inches thick, yellowish green with grooves, no hairs |
| Leaves | Three broad, lobed leaflets, not deeply cut; about 2 to 2.5 feet wide | Deeply cut and jagged, up to 5 feet wide | 5 to 15 toothed leaflets along a stalk, up to about 1 foot long |
| Flower heads | White, flat-topped, up to about 1 foot wide | White, umbrella-shaped, up to 2.5 feet wide | Yellow, flat-topped, about 4 to 8 inches wide |
Sources: dec.ny.gov, dec.ny.gov, nwcb.wa.gov, extension.umn.edu
Wild garlic and wild onion vs. star-of-Bethlehem
Star-of-Bethlehem grows in the same lawns and looks like wild onion or garlic before it flowers, but its bulbs hold heart-affecting poisons. In the West, deadly death camas has also been mistaken for wild onion, and its bulbs lack an onion smell too.
The quick rule: No onion or garlic smell, no eating. Crush a leaf every time.
- Wild garlic — Edible
Round, hollow leaves like chives that smell strongly of garlic when crushed. - Wild onion — Edible
Flat, grass-like leaves that smell strongly of onion when crushed. - Star-of-Bethlehem — harmful
No onion or garlic smell, and a pale stripe runs down the middle of each glossy leaf.
| Feature | Wild garlic | Wild onion | Star-of-Bethlehem |
|---|---|---|---|
| Smell of a crushed leaf | Strong garlic | Strong onion | No garlic or onion smell |
| Leaves | Slender, round and hollow, like chives | Flat and grass-like | Narrow, smooth and glossy, with a pale green to white stripe down the middle; often bend down in the middle |
| Height | Leaves stay about half as tall as wild garlic | ||
| Flowers | Small white to purplish flowers mixed with little bulblets at the top of the stalk | Pink or white star-shaped flowers, often mixed with bulblets | White six-petaled stars with a green stripe on the back of each petal; open around midday, close in the evening |
Sources: plants.ces.ncsu.edu, plants.ces.ncsu.edu, turf.purdue.edu, ag.purdue.edu, plants.ces.ncsu.edu, extension.usu.edu
Purslane vs. spotted spurge and prostrate spurge
Purslane and spurges form flat, reddish mats in the same sunny beds and sidewalk cracks. Purslane is eaten, but spurge sap is poisonous and irritates skin and eyes.
The quick rule: Snap a stem: milky white sap means spurge. Don't eat it.
- Common purslane — Edible
Thick, fleshy, smooth stems and leaves, with clear (not milky) sap. - Spotted Spurge — harmful
Broken stems ooze milky white sap, and most leaves have a dark red spot in the middle. - Prostrate spurge — harmful
Broken stems ooze milky white sap.
| Feature | Common purslane | Spotted spurge | Prostrate spurge |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sap from a broken stem | Clear | Milky white | Milky white |
| Stems | Thick, fleshy, smooth and reddish | Thin, wiry, reddish and hairy | Thin, pinkish and hairy |
| Leaves | Thick, succulent, smooth and paddle-shaped | Small, thin and oval, in pairs, usually with a dark red spot in the middle | Small (1/8 to 1/2 inch), pale green and hairy, in pairs, with a small reddish-brown spot |
| Flowers | Small yellow flowers that open on sunny mornings | Tiny, whitish pink | Tiny, whitish pink |
Sources: extension.msstate.edu, extension.umn.edu, ipm.ucanr.edu, ipm.ucanr.edu, purduelandscapereport.org
Elderberry vs. pokeweed and water hemlock
Elderberry's dark purple berries can be confused with pokeberries, and its flat white flower clusters look like water hemlock's. Both look-alikes are far more dangerous, and even elderberry makes people sick if eaten raw or unripe.
The quick rule: Elderberry is a woody shrub. Soft purple-red stems or berries on long hanging strings mean pokeweed; soft hollow stems in wet ground mean hemlock.
- Elderberry (American) — Edible
A woody shrub with leaves split into 5 to 11 leaflets; only fully ripe, cooked dark purple berries are eaten, since raw or unripe berries, leaves and stems make people sick. - Pokeweed — Deadly
Smooth, soft purple-red stems and berries lined up on long, hanging stalks. - Water hemlock — Deadly
A soft-stemmed plant, not a shrub, with hollow, purple-streaked stems and umbrella-shaped flower clusters, usually in wet ground.
| Feature | Elderberry (American) | Pokeweed (pokeberry) | Water hemlock |
|---|---|---|---|
| Plant | Woody shrub 5 to 12 feet, with yellowish-gray bark and white pith | Soft-stemmed (not woody), 3 to 8 feet, with a large fleshy taproot | Soft-stemmed, 2 to 8 feet, with hollow stems streaked or mottled purple |
| Leaves | Compound: 5 to 11 sharply toothed leaflets on each leaf | Smooth, single (not divided) leaves, often reddish underneath | Divided two or three times into narrow, toothed leaflets |
| Flower and berry clusters | Broad, flat-topped clusters with no single main stalk; heavy berry clusters can droop | Berries lined up along a long, purple central stalk that hangs down like a string | White umbrella-shaped clusters (umbels) |
| Stems | Woody branches | Smooth, bright purple-red, not woody | Hollow, with purple streaks or mottling |
Sources: plants.ces.ncsu.edu, mdc.mo.gov, mdc.mo.gov, extension.umd.edu, ipm.missouri.edu, plants.ces.ncsu.edu
Grapes vs. pokeberries and other vine berries
Clusters of dark purple berries hanging at a child's eye level get mistaken for grapes. Pokeberries, Virginia creeper berries and porcelain berries are all poisonous, and so is moonseed, a vine with grape-like berries and a single crescent-shaped seed.
The quick rule: Real grapes grow on a woody vine with curling tendrils, toothed leaves and shredding bark. Missing any of these? Don't eat it.
- Grape — Edible
A woody vine with curling tendrils, toothed leaves, shredding bark and brown pith. - Pokeweed — Deadly
Not a vine: berries hang on soft red stalks from a tall, non-woody plant. - Virginia creeper — harmful
Each leaf has five leaflets from one point, and tendrils end in sticky pads. - Porcelain berry — harmful
Berries in mixed colors (white, yellow, lilac, green, turquoise, bright blue) held upright above the vine, with white pith inside the stem.
| Feature | Grape (including wild grape) | Pokeweed (pokeberry) | Virginia creeper | Porcelain berry |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| How it grows | Woody climbing vine with curling tendrils | Upright, soft-stemmed plant with a deep taproot; not a vine | Vine or ground cover; tendrils end in adhesive disks | Climbing vine |
| Leaves | Toothed leaves | Smooth, undivided leaves | Five toothed leaflets spreading from one point, like a hand | Heart-shaped with coarse teeth |
| Berries | Hang in drooping clusters | Glossy dark purple, hanging on long purple-red stalks; leave a purple-red stain | Small, dark blue | Mixed colors, often bright blue, held upright above the stem |
| Bark and pith | Bark shreds and peels; pith (center of the stem) is brown | Bark does not peel; pith is white |
Sources: poison.org, extension.psu.edu, extension.umd.edu, extension.umd.edu, hgic.clemson.edu, mdc.mo.gov
Poison ivy vs. Virginia creeper and poison oak
Poison ivy and Virginia creeper often climb the same trees and fences, and poison oak looks like a shrubby poison ivy. Poison ivy and poison oak carry urushiol oil, which causes an itchy, blistering rash; box elder seedlings, which also have three leaflets, are harmless.
The quick rule: Leaves of three, let it be. Leaves of five, let it thrive, but don't eat the berries.
- Poison ivy — harmful
Three leaflets on each leaf; climbing vines look hairy from their aerial roots. - Virginia creeper — harmful
Five leaflets from one point; it lacks poison ivy's rash oil (at most a mild rash), but its berries are poisonous. - Atlantic poison oak — harmful
Three fuzzy leaflets with rounded, oak-like lobes on a low, upright shrub. - Western poison oak — harmful
Three leaflets with the middle one on the longest stalk; a shrub in sun and a climbing vine in shade.
| Feature | Poison ivy | Virginia creeper | Atlantic poison oak (eastern) | Western poison oak (Pacific) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Leaflets per leaf | Three; edges smooth, toothed or lobed | Five, spreading from one point like a hand | Three, with rounded oak-like lobes | Three (rarely 5 or 7), toothed or lobed; the middle one has the longest stalk |
| How it climbs or grows | Vine with hairy-looking aerial roots, or a low shrub or ground cover | Vine with tendrils ending in sticky disks, or a ground cover | Low, upright shrub, usually 2 to 4 feet | Dense shrub 1 to 6 feet in sun; climbs with aerial roots in shade |
| Berries | White to greenish-yellow clusters | Small, dark blue | Fuzzy, greenish-white to tan-white | Whitish green, smooth |
| Leaf texture | Toothed leaflets | Stems and leaves finely fuzzy on both sides | ||
| Leaf arrangement (vs. box elder seedlings) | Leaves alternate along the stem; box elder seedlings have 3 to 5 leaflets but their leaves grow in opposite pairs |
Sources: extension.psu.edu, extension.okstate.edu, cdc.gov, ipm.ucanr.edu, plants.ces.ncsu.edu, hgic.clemson.edu
Ground cherry vs. horsenettle, black nightshade and buffalobur
Ground cherries are nightshade-family plants that come up among weedy nightshade relatives with small tomato-like berries. The weeds' leaves and berries are poisonous, especially when green, and even ground cherries are toxic until fully ripe.
The quick rule: Eat only golden ground cherries that come in a dry, papery husk. No husk, a spiny husk, or prickly stems? Don't eat it.
- Ground cherry — Edible
Each fruit grows inside a papery husk and is eaten only when fully ripe and golden; green fruit, leaves and stems are toxic. - Horsenettle — harmful
Sharp yellow or white spines on the stems and leaves, and no husk on the berries. - Eastern black nightshade — Deadly
Shiny purple-black berries in small hanging clusters with no husk; green berries are the most poisonous. - Buffalobur — harmful
Covered in yellow spines, and each berry is sealed inside a spiny bur.
| Feature | Ground cherry | Horsenettle | Eastern black nightshade | Buffalobur |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fruit covering | Inside a loose, inflated, papery beige to tan husk | No husk; smooth berries like tiny tomatoes | No husk; the small green calyx doesn't cover the berry | Completely sealed inside a spiny husk (bur) |
| Ripe fruit | Golden yellow, cherry-sized; drops to the ground when ripe | Like tiny tomatoes, turning golden yellow | Shiny purple-black, about 3/8 inch | Hidden inside the bur |
| Spines and prickles | None | Sharp yellow or white spines on stems and leaves | None | Yellow spines almost everywhere |
| Flowers | Creamy yellow, often with purple centers | Small white to pale purple stars with yellow centers | Yellow, about 1 inch across |
Sources: extension.psu.edu, ipm.missouri.edu, cals.cornell.edu, cals.cornell.edu, hortsense.cahnrs.wsu.edu, hortsense.cahnrs.wsu.edu
Prickly lettuce (wild lettuce) vs. sowthistle, dandelion and chicory
These weeds all ooze milky sap and have toothed, dandelion-like leaves. Prickly lettuce, also sold under names like wild lettuce and wild opium, is very bitter, fresh young plants can sicken cattle, and a close relative also called wild lettuce has put people in the hospital, so it is not one to eat.
The quick rule: Flip the leaf: a row of stiff prickles under the midrib means prickly lettuce. Don't eat it.
- Prickly lettuce — harmful
A row of stiff prickles along the underside of the leaf midrib. - Annual sowthistle — Edible
Soft-spined leaves whose clawlike bases wrap around a smooth, hollow stem. - Dandelion — Edible
No leafy stem: one yellow flower head sits alone on each hollow, leafless stalk. - Chicory — Edible
Bright blue flower heads on tall stems; rough, hairy leaves.
| Feature | Prickly lettuce (wild lettuce) | Annual sowthistle | Dandelion | Chicory |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Underside of the leaf | Row of stiff prickles along the midrib; leaf edges prickly too | Soft spines on the leaf edges | Sparsely hairy or hairless, no prickles | Rough and hairy, with hairs along the midrib |
| Stem and leaf base | Tall, branched, hollow leafy stem; leaves clasp it and often turn edge-up | Smooth, thick, hollow leafy stem; upper leaves wrap it with clawlike lobes | No leafy stem, just a flat rosette | Tall, wiry stems 2 to 4 feet |
| Milky sap | Yes, throughout the plant | Yes, from cut stems | Yes, from leaves, stalks and roots | Yes, from the cut root |
| Flowers | Small yellow heads (under 1/2 inch) in open, branched clusters; turn blue as they wither | Yellow dandelion-like heads in clusters at stem tips | One bright yellow head per hollow, leafless stalk | Bright blue heads 1 to 1.5 inches wide that close by midday |
Sources: sare.org, pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov, ipm.ucanr.edu, ipm.ucanr.edu, extension.umn.edu, plants.ces.ncsu.edu
Stinging nettle vs. henbit and purple deadnettle
Deadnettles are named for leaves that look like nettle leaves, and all three have square stems and paired leaves. Only stinging nettle has stinging hairs that burn and itch on contact.
The quick rule: Wear gloves until you know. Stinging hairs and tiny green flower clusters mean nettle; purple lipped flowers and no stinging hairs mean a deadnettle.
- Stinging nettle — harmful
Stinging hairs on the stems and leaves cause a burning, itchy sting (NC State notes young shoots are eaten only after cooking). - Henbit — Edible
No stinging hairs; rounded, scalloped upper leaves with no stalks that wrap around the stem. - Purple Deadnettle — Edible
No stinging hairs; heart-shaped upper leaves on short stalks, tinged purple at the top.
| Feature | Stinging nettle | Henbit | Purple deadnettle |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stinging hairs | Yes, on stems and leaves | None | None (that's why it's called 'dead' nettle) |
| Leaves | Egg-shaped, 1 to 6 inches, with a pointed tip and coarse saw-tooth edges | Rounded and coarsely scalloped; upper leaves have no stalks and wrap the stem | Heart-shaped, hairy and crowded at the top, where they are purplish; all leaves have stalks |
| Flowers | Tiny green or white flowers in clusters where leaves meet the stem | Purple, tube-shaped and two-lipped, in rings around the upper stem | Purplish, tube-shaped and two-lipped |
| Stems | Square, with stinging hairs | Square, often purple-tinged | Square |
Sources: plants.ces.ncsu.edu, plants.ces.ncsu.edu, turffiles.ncsu.edu, plants.ces.ncsu.edu, henderson.ces.ncsu.edu
Mock strawberry vs. strawberry
Mock strawberry trails through lawns and bears little red strawberry-like fruits. It isn't a poisoning risk, but the fruit is bland and dry, not a real strawberry.
The quick rule: Yellow flowers mean mock strawberry; real strawberries have white flowers.
- Mock Strawberry — Harmless
Yellow five-petaled flowers. - Strawberry — Edible
White (sometimes pink) five-petaled flowers with yellow centers.
| Feature | Mock strawberry (Indian strawberry) | Strawberry |
|---|---|---|
| Flowers | Yellow, five petals | White to pinkish, five petals, yellow center |
| Leaf teeth | Rounded teeth | Toothed leaflets (wild strawberry's teeth are sharp-pointed) |
| Fruit | Small and bright red, with little red seeds on a bumpy surface | Larger red fruit with seeds set in a pitted surface |
| Taste | Bland and dry | Sweet |
Sources: turffiles.ncsu.edu, plants.ces.ncsu.edu, plants.ces.ncsu.edu, extension.umd.edu
Parsley and fennel vs. poison hemlock
Poison hemlock gets mistaken for parsley, anise, fennel and other carrot-family herbs, and adults have been poisoned this way. Eating even a small amount can kill.
The quick rule: Only harvest carrot-family herbs you know you planted. Purple-spotted stem or musty smell? It's hemlock.
- Parsley — Edible
Thin, green, hollow stems without spots, and greenish-yellow flowers in its second year. - Fennel — Edible
Needle-thin, yellow-green leaves with a sweet anise or licorice smell. - Poison hemlock — Deadly
Smooth, hollow stems spotted or streaked with purple, and a musty smell when crushed.
| Feature | Parsley | Fennel | Poison hemlock |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stem | Long, thin, hollow and green | Smooth and hollow, with purple or red spots and streaks | |
| Smell | Sweet anise or licorice | Musty or unpleasant, like mouse urine | |
| Leaves | Dark green, curly or flat | Feathery, yellow-green, needle-like segments | Hairless, finely cut, lacy and fern-like |
| Flowers | Greenish yellow | Yellow | White |
Sources: ipm.ucanr.edu, kingcounty.gov, plants.ces.ncsu.edu, plants.ces.ncsu.edu, poison.org, extension.psu.edu
Horseradish vs. monkshood
Monkshood roots have been dug up and eaten by mistake for horseradish. Monkshood (not covered elsewhere in this app) is deadly: its poison can stop the heart within hours.
The quick rule: Only dig roots under big, undivided horseradish leaves. Hand-shaped leaves or hooded blue-purple flowers mean monkshood: don't dig, don't taste.
- Horseradish — Edible
Very large, long, undivided leaves with toothed edges, rising from a thick, sharp-smelling root.
| Feature | Horseradish |
|---|---|
| Leaves | Large (up to 2 feet long), oblong to oval and undivided, with toothed edges. Monkshood leaves are split like a hand into 5 to 7 deep segments. |
| Flowers | Small, white, four-petaled flowers in dense clusters. Monkshood has showy blue-purple flowers topped with a hood. |
| Root | A thick root that gives off a sharp, hot smell when cut. Monkshood grows from fleshy tubers shaped like little turnips. |
Sources: uaex.uada.edu, plants.ces.ncsu.edu
Borage vs. foxglove
Young foxglove leaves have been picked by mistake for borage and eaten, slowing and even stopping the heart. Foxglove (not covered elsewhere in this app) is poisonous in every part and can kill.
The quick rule: Pick borage leaves only from plants you know are borage, ideally in bloom with blue star flowers. A leafy rosette with no flowers could be foxglove.
- Borage — Edible
Bright blue, drooping star-shaped flowers and bristly, wrinkled leaves (eat sparingly: the leaves hold liver-harming compounds).
| Feature | Borage |
|---|---|
| Flowers | Bright blue, drooping, star-shaped, under 1 inch. Foxglove has tube-shaped bells, spotted inside, lined up one side of a tall spike. |
| Leaves | Gray-green, wrinkled, up to 6 inches, covered in bristly hairs. First-year foxglove makes a low rosette of coarse, velvety leaves up to a foot long. |
| Growth | Annual that flowers the same year it sprouts. Foxglove grows only leaves the first year and flowers in the second. |
Sources: poison.org, plants.ces.ncsu.edu, plants.ces.ncsu.edu